Submit Response

SparkStats

Submit Response is a weblog by Jack Mottram, a journalist who lives in Glasgow, Scotland. There are 1308 posts in the archives. You can subscribe to a feed. This post was made on January 24, 2005 and belongs in the books category. The previous post was , and the next post is .

Godly Mot

Since Christ­mas, I’ve been slowly work­ing my way through Hamlet’s Mill: An Essay Inves­ti­gat­ing The Ori­gins of Human Knowl­edge And Its Trans­mis­sion Through Myth by Gior­gio De San­til­lana & Hertha Von Dechend. It’s a fas­ci­nat­ing read, despite being eso­ter­i­cally organ­ised, bone dry and, frankly, rid­dled with much bunkum.

In brief, De San­til­lana & Von Dechend reckon that common themes in the mythol­ogy of uncon­nected cul­tures are not evi­dence of the col­lec­tive uncon­scious Chinese-​whispering records of cat­a­clysmic events in pre-​history, but proof that myths are cod­i­fied memetic trans­mis­sion devices for detailed astro­log­i­cal and pseudo-​scientific knowl­edge from the ear­li­est human civil­i­sa­tions. Some­thing like that, anyway.

They seem to be on to some­thing, or at least capa­ble of forg­ing links between myths and astro­nom­i­cal knowl­edge - they’re cer­tainly con­vinc­ing when it comes to, say, the asser­tion that all prim­i­tive cul­tures under­stood equinoc­tal pre­ces­sion, and that the struc­ture of a whole host of myths can be inter­preted as relat­ing to that knowl­edge - but I’ll save fur­ther notes for a future post when I’ve fin­ished the book.

For the time being, I’ll just share this snip­pet quoted from the Ras Shamra texts, myths of the Ugarit (better known as Canaan­ites), those clever folk who invented the 30-letter ur-​alphabet from which all pho­netic alpha­bets derive. For obvi­ous rea­sons, it made me piss myself:

She seizes the Godly Mot
With swords she does cleave him
With fan she does winnow him
With fire she does burn him
With hand-​mill she grinds him
In the field she does sow him
Birds eat his rem­nants
Con­sum­ing his por­tions
Flit­ting from rem­nant to remnant.

(Con­cerned read­ers will be pleased to learn that my godly name­sake some­how man­ages to spring back to life a couple of clay tablets later.)

Posted at 6pm on 24/01/05 by Jack Mottram to the books category.
Permalink · Add to del.icio.us
Tags: , ,

  1. when you finish there will then be three people in the whole world who have read it - assum­ing de san­til­lana and von dechend read each others con­tri­bu­tion. i tried but after three pages my head started spin­ning off its own axis. precession?

    Posted by godlymotdad at 11pm on 24.01.05

  2. It’s good to know that you’ve been around that long. Maybe this is the second coming of Mot.
    It all started here, on Submit Response.

    Posted by Donny at 10am on 25.01.05

  3. Dad - my friend Guy, who got me the book for Christ­mas, is actu­ally re -reading it at the moment. You should’ve seen his attempt to explain the wob­bling of earth axes through the medium of hand ges­tures in the pub the other day…

    Don - yeah, I’ll be bat­tling the mighty god Baal on top of some moun­tain this week­end. If I win, we enter the age of Aquar­ius. Quite a resposi­bil­ity, but someone’s got to do it…

    Posted by Jack Mottram at 2pm on 25.01.05

  4. now that you are our sav­iour mot, we promise not to cru­cify you and will wor­ship at the mighty alter of submit response for all eternity*

    hee

    Posted by badgergirl at 10am on 26.01.05

  5. eek

    that should say altar not alter

    Posted by badgergirl at 11am on 26.01.05

Leave a comment:




Alternatively, you can log in using OpenID



If you know HTML, you can use these tags in your comment: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> Alternatively, you can use Markdown syntax.

Safari hates me

Recent Posts

Categories

Archives

Elsewhere

Search